Where and How to Sell Baby Stuff and Actually Make Money

TL;DR:

When selling baby stuff, the best option depends on how much time, effort and payout you want:

• Local resale stores are quick and simple, but payouts are usually low and item acceptance is limited.
• Peer-to-peer selling on platforms like Facebook Marketplace can bring higher earnings, but requires time for photos, messaging and meetups.
• Online resale platforms like GoodBuy Gear make selling bulky or premium baby gear easier, offering expert quality checks and safety inspections and higher payouts with less hassle.

For parents looking to maximize earnings while minimizing effort, online resale — especially with trusted services like GoodBuy Gear — is often the most profitable and stress-free choice.

——————

Babies grow fast, and before you know it, every corner of your house is overflowing with strollers, car seats, swings and toys collecting dust. Selling these items instead of letting them sit around can help you turn them into cash for other things, like the baby walker your increasingly active little one could use. And it doesn’t have to feel like a full-time side hustle. 

If you’re wondering where or how to sell baby stuff without wasting time, this guide breaks down your options, from local resale shops to online platforms, so you can figure out what makes the most sense for you.

Where Can You Sell Baby Stuff? 

Not all resale options are the same. Here’s a quick look at the main ways to sell baby stuff, so you can weigh effort, payout and convenience before deciding what’s right for you.

Local Resale & Consignment Stores

Local resale or thrift stores are the quickest way to offload gear. You simply drop off books, toys, swings and clothes, and the store handles the selling. There’s minimal effort required on your part, and you don’t have to deal with setting prices or negotiating with buyers. Often, the payout is instant, though some consignment stores pay out once your item sells. There are downsides, though, including much lower payouts and limited item acceptance. 

Best items to sell via local resale: Clothing, books, toys and other smaller items.

Peer-to-Peer Marketplaces

Selling on platforms like Facebook Marketplace, Buy/Sell/Trade groups, Poshmark or Mercari can earn you more since you set your own price, especially for in-demand items. But it does take time to take photos, answer messages and coordinate pick-ups. Bulky gear can be tricky to manage, and buyers may try to negotiate.

Best items to sell via local resale: Baby carriers, high chairs, toys and clothing bundles. 

Online Baby Gear Resale Platforms

Online resale platforms like GoodBuy Gear offer the convenience of shipping or drop-off, often higher payouts and access to a national audience of parents looking for gently used gear. GoodBuy Gear specifically has spent years developing a proprietary quality and safety check process, so you don’t have to worry about whether a stroller or car seat meets safety standards. This makes it easier to sell premium or bulky items with confidence, without spending hours on photos, messages and meetups… because who actually has time for that? 

Best items to sell via local resale: Premium and bulky gear like strollers, wagons, car seats, bassinets, cribs, swings and high-end carriers.

How to Sell Baby Stuff Locally and Peer-to-Peer 

Selling Locally

To sell locally, search online for “baby consignment near me,” check parenting groups or ask friends for recommendations. Make sure items are clean, in good condition and include any manuals or accessories. Always check the store’s acceptance policy before dropping items off.

Pros: Minimal effort, no direct buyer interactions, sometimes instant payout or store credit
Cons: Lower payouts, limited items accepted, pricing can vary

Peer-to-Peer Selling

To sell gently used baby gear peer-to-peer, take clear photos, write detailed descriptions and respond promptly to messages. Always arrange safe meetups or contactless pickups.

Pros: Potentially higher payouts, you set your own price, can sell in-demand items quickly
Cons: Time-consuming, bulky items can be hard to coordinate, buyers may haggle 

How To Sell Baby Stuff Online

Online resale is growing because it makes selling and buying discounted baby gear easier and faster. It’s also often more profitable for the seller. Platforms like GoodBuy Gear connect you with parents nationwide, so in-demand items (especially large or bulky gear like strollers, car seats and playards) sell more quickly.

Why parents like online resale:

• Access to a larger audience than local shops
• Often higher payouts for popular or premium items
• Less time spent haggling or coordinating meetups
• Platforms handle much of the heavy lifting

Online resale sites handle pricing guidance, show what’s most likely to sell and provide estimates for payouts and sell-through times. Many also manage shipping and logistics, so you don’t have to worry about arranging meetups or packing bulky items yourself. Platforms like GoodBuy Gear also perform quality checks and safety inspections, giving buyers confidence in your items while saving you time and stress.

How Selling With GoodBuy Gear Works 

Through GoodBuy Gear, parents can safely and easily sell sought-after baby gear like strollers, car seats, playards, baby carriers, wagons and breast pumps. . 

In the NYC area, items can be dropped off or picked up, and, if you aren’t in the NYC area, you have the option to mail-in certain items. For peace of mind, they inspect every item for safety, functionality and missing parts before listing them on their site. 

Here’s how to sell your baby gear with GoodBuy Gear: 

1. Submit your items

• White glove pickup: Schedule a pickup in the NYC area, and gear specialists will collect your items from your doorstep. You can also opt to drop off your items at GoodBuy Gear’s Brooklyn location. Once your item sells, the company deducts $10 for drop-offs and $25 for pickups. 
• Sell by mail: Mail in eligible items from anywhere — no need to leave home. Simply complete an online form to generate a shipping label, then pack up your items and drop them off at FedEx. 

2. Price your items

• GoodBuy Gear suggests a price for each item based on the current retail price, its condition, third-party market data and historical resale data from similar items. You can accept the recommended price or adjust it — final pricing is always your call.
• Payouts are based on the final selling price minus handling fees. The price used to calculate your payout will always be visible in your seller account, though pricing shown on the website may vary over time. 

3. Wait for your item to sell

• After passing functionality and quality checks, items are prepared and listed for sale. GoodBuy Gear handles it all — professional photos, accurate product descriptions, pricing updates and exposure to a nationwide audience. 
• Sellers don’t have to manage listings, messages or follow-ups while their item is on the market.

4. Get paid

• Once your item sells and the buyer receives it, your earnings are added to your account after a short processing window. Payouts are based on a sliding scale, meaning higher-value items earn a larger percentage.
• You can track all listings, sales, and payout status directly in your seller account. When your balance reaches $5 or more, you can choose how to cash out: store credit, direct deposit or donation. 

Our Quality and Safety Inspection Process

Safety and quality are top priorities when reselling baby gear. At GoodBuy Gear, every item is inspected for functionality, missing parts, cleanliness and safety compliance before being listed for sale. This gives parents confidence that all items are clean, functional and safe for their children.

Car Seats

Gently used car seats go through a special GoodBuy™ Car Seat Safety Check. Certified technicians ensure seats have never been in a crash, are not recalled, are within expiration and pass 30 safety checks. Sellers must also attest to ownership and safe usage when selling car seats. 

Refurbishment
Some items receive certified refurbishment. This may include replacing approved spare parts or securely wiping data from smart devices. Items that fail safety, authenticity or compliance standards are never refurbished or resold.

Recalls

Safety is a top priority, and recalled items are never accepted for resale. GoodBuy Gear actively monitors Consumer Product Safety Commission recall lists, and listings are automatically flagged if an item has an active recall. 

If an item purchased is later recalled, manufacturers provide instructions for repairs, vouchers or refunds. Support is also available to help guide parents through the process.

What Baby Items Are Most Profitable To Sell?

Some used baby gear consistently sells faster and earns higher payouts because it’s in high demand, from trusted brands or simply expensive to buy new. Condition matters, though, and items that are gently used, clean and in full working order are the most appealing to buyers.

Strollers and wagons
High-quality strollers are always in demand, especially premium or modular options. Popular models like the Bugaboo Butterfly and Wonderfold tend to retain value because parents want a reliable, well-reviewed stroller without paying full price.

Car seats
Gently used car seats are in high demand, because parents want safe, reliable options without paying full price. Infant car seats like the UPPAbaby MESA and convertible seats like the Evenflo Revolve 360 tend to sell well when they’re clean, fully functional and within their expiration dates. 

High chairs
Well-made high chairs, like the Stokke Tripp Trapp, and durable booster seats like the Lalo Booster often hold value, because parents look for safe, long-lasting feeding solutions.

Swings, bouncers and activity gear
Electronic swings, bouncers and activity centers like the 4moms mamaRoo or the Lovevery Play Gym are popular, because they’re only used for a short time and are expensive to buy new. 

What Baby Items Can You Not Resell?

Some items aren’t safe or practical to resell. Here’s a quick guide:

• Broken or unsafe gear: Anything damaged or missing parts can put a child at risk.
• Recalled items: Reselling recalled products is illegal and unsafe.
• Old strollers and bike trailers: Items over 10 years old may no longer meet current safety standards.
• Crib mattresses and bedding: These items are hard to clean and can harbor bacteria. 
• Large furniture and bulky outdoor gear: Beds, gliders, changing tables, playhouses, slides and similar items are difficult to ship, inspect and resell safely.
• Clothing, shoes, soft toys and books: These items are often low value, can’t be thoroughly sanitized and sell poorly.
• End-of-life or outdated items: Any gear that is no longer safe or no longer supported by the manufacturer.

Items that can’t be resold safely can often be donated to local charities, shelters or recycling programs. This keeps clutter out of the house and helps other families in need without compromising safety.

How to Make More Money When Selling Baby Gear: 6 Tips 

Getting the most out of your gently used baby gear isn’t just about what you sell, it’s how you sell it. A few simple strategies can help boost your payout and make the process smoother:

• Keep gear clean and well-stored: Wipe down items, launder fabrics and store them in a dry, safe place until sale.
• Include all accessories and manuals: Original boxes, instruction manuals and extra parts increase buyer confidence.
• Sell items promptly: Gear sells best when it’s still in style and hasn’t been outgrown for long.
• Choose the right resale channel: Local shops, peer-to-peer marketplaces and online resale platforms each have different payout potential and convenience. Pick the one that fits your item and schedule.
• Highlight brand and condition: Premium brands like UPPAbaby and Nuna in excellent condition tend to sell faster and for more money.
• Take clear photos and write detailed descriptions: Good lighting, multiple angles and honesty about condition help items move quickly.

Baby Gear Resale FAQ 

Is Selling Baby Products Profitable?

Yes, selling gently-used baby products can be profitable, especially for high-demand, premium items like strollers, car seats and baby swings. Even smaller gear can bring in extra cash if listed thoughtfully. Condition, brand and timing all affect resale value, so clean, complete items sold soon after they’re outgrown tend to earn the most. 

What Baby Items Sell Best Secondhand?

The baby items that sell best secondhand are high-demand, durable and premium gear like strollers, convertible car seats, carriers, high chairs and swings from well-known brands like UPPAbaby, Stokke and BabyBjorn. Items in excellent condition with all parts, accessories and manuals move fastest.

Can You Resell Baby Items Safely?

Yes, baby items can be resold safely as long as they’re clean, fully functional and free of recalls. Reputable resale platforms like GoodBuy Gear perform thorough inspections to ensure safety when giving baby gear a second life. 

So, What is the Best Place to Sell Baby Stuff? 

The best place to sell baby gear depends on your priorities: time, effort and payout. 

• Local resale or consignment stores are best for parents who want minimal effort, instant payout and are ok with lower returns.
• Peer-to-peer marketplaces are best for parents willing to invest time in photos, messaging and meetups to potentially earn more on popular items.
• Online resale platforms like GoodBuy Gear are ideal for parents who want a higher payout on premium or bulky gear with less hassle.

Ultimately, the right choice depends on your schedule, your gear and how much effort you’re willing to put in, but for many parents, online resale platforms offer the perfect balance of convenience, safety and fair payouts.