The Top 3 Breast Pumps Reviewed—and What Look For When Buying Used

Just about every mom needs a breast pump in her life, be that for months, days or multiple pregnancies. Often we get one thrust on us sight, and review, unseen from our insurance company, but that doesn't mean it's the best on the market or that it works the best for your lifestyle. We enlisted Kristin Hood, a baby gear expert to try out the top three breast pumps and gave us her unbiased review. 

Even better, when you're done nursing you can pass your gently used machine off to another mother. And if you're on the receiving end, here's what you should be looking for in a gently used pump. 

Here's how to best shop for, sell and maintain your breast pump so it can go the distance and service you, your baby and other families down the line. 

The Reviews Are In 


Retails for $499
Pros: I love this pump. It's made my pumping life so much easier and truly possible. I would never have been able to continue nursing as long as I have without it. It is a great pump for moms on the go, when having your second child, or basically once you don't have time to be attached to a wall or giant pump anymore. It's quiet, cordless and fits right into your bra. I can pump while working, driving, walking the dog, doing dishes or giving the kids a bath. I've even dropped my son at school with it in! Just wore a big jacket over top and no one knew. Plus it's FSA and HSA eligible and has great resale value.

Cons: It does take some time to get the hang of placing it correctly and getting the right amount of suction for your needs. Once you get the hang of it it's easy-peasy. However, this is not a pump for moms who pump over five-ounces easily at each pumping session. You would need to pay close attention to make sure it doesn't overflow or use the app to keep tracking of how full it's getting. Keep in mind it only holds a charge for about three, 20-to-30-minute pumping sessions, so you must re-charge each night.

Tips: This is not a pump you can come home from the hospital with and start using. I would recommend using it once your supply is established and you are on a solid pumping schedule. You pump into reusable bottles so you then need to transfer the milk to a freezer bag if you are storing milk. 

Purchase new: link

Purchase gently used: link

Spectra S1 Plus

Retails for $200

Pros: When you first start pumping and come home from the hospital this is the pump you want by your side. It has strong suction and is rechargeable so you aren't tied to a wall. The charge lasts a long time. It has a timer on it, night-light and lots of other functions to help with getting the most out of your pumping. You can modify your settings and save them to fit your needs. I used this for the first three to four months home with my new baby. 

Cons: There actually aren't any big cons. This is an amazing pump and if you can only afford one pump, I'd get this one. 

Tips: I got this pump through my insurance but still had to pay $80 out of pocket to get the S1 upgrade. Only S2 is usually fully covered, but I think it's worth the upgrade to get the S1. You do need to use an actual pumping bra when using this pump. Also, Spectra offers free pumping support from a lactation specialist, they will talk you through how to pump, how long and different cycles to try to promote more milk at each session. It was incredibly helpful for me and it's free. 

Pumping bra: link

Support: link

Purchase new: link

Purchase gently used: link

Medela Harmony Manual Hand Pump

Retails for $29

Pros: This is a great pump to just have for when you need to do a quick pump in the bathroom at a wedding or work event. It gets the job done but you have to manually pump yourself. It's also inexpensive, another plus.

Cons: I would not recommend using this if you need to fully empty your breast. It also takes time since it's manual and you can only do one breast at a time.

Tips: I like to keep one on hand to throw in my purse if I'm headed out to a late dinner, wedding or event and need some relief. Or use in the middle of the night when baby starts sleeping longer and you need relief as time between feeds lengthen.

Purchase new: link

Purchase gently used: link

How To Buy a Gently Used Breast Pump

We get it. A breast pump is a personal thing that not only attaches to your body, but helps extract the milk that keeps your baby strong. It can get messy, but that doesn't mean these devices can't be cleaned and sanitized. For starters, Good Buy Gear only takes second-hand pumps that look mostly new. That means there aren't stains, wear or large marks on any of the pumps, parts or bottles. Sometimes there might be a water spot from washing, and even though we sell them to you clean it's always a good idea to run bottles through the dishwasher with your own, preferred soap. Good Buy Gear also checks the pumps for suction to make sure you will be getting the most out of both the products and your breasts. 

Check out the line up including Medela, Spectra, Bellababy, Evenflo and more.

How To Keep Your Pump In Good Order

Whether you want to sell a breast pump after you're done nursing or want to keep it for the next baby, there are ways to make sure it can last. The first and best thing you can do to maintain the life of this device is to wipe it down after each use. Grab a baby wipe, damp cloth or even a tissue to make sure there's not milk spillage hardening on the surface. You will also want to clean the parts as soon as you are done, using warm to hot water and soap. Let them air dry. These methods not only will keep the pump and accessories clean, but sanitizes the baby gear for your own child. 

As for the machine itself, try not to over run it. Keep your pumps to 30 minutes or less, which should be more than enough time to empty out the breast. This way you won't be overheating the device and it will maintain proper function. If you notice the suction not working as well as before, look into replacing valves and tubes. There could be a pinprick hole or loss of elasticity in the silicone. Pumps that have motors that have slowed down should be recycled since unfortunately they can't be easily fixed. 

Photo credit: Mukhina1

Previous article Sell Your Gear In More Ways with buybuy Baby & Good Buy Gear


Renee Hudlow - June 15, 2021

The Motif duo pump should definitely make this list! I switched partway through and Loved the motif duo. I used it till my daughter was thirteen months. It was smaller, held battery charge for a long time, and I could slip it in a large (not jeans, but sometimes dress or shorts) pocket and walk around when I pumped. I also liked being able to program it for the different settings for different times. It’s not as well known, but it was great! Also, we tried 15+ bottles with my daughter and the ones that came with the duo were the only one she ever accepted (though they were not the first nor last we tried). The only problem is that they only offer slow flow nipples so we had to switch her to a straw cup at six months.

Leave a comment

Comments must be approved before appearing

* Required fields

What strollers are right for my family?

Which size interests you?

Show All

How will you mostly be using this stroller?

Everyday standard use
Travel or on lots of public transit

Do you have a specific budget in mind?

Less than $100
$100 - $250
Greater than $250
Show me all

Select any features that are very important to you

Height adjustable handlebar
Converts from a single to a double
Reversible parent-facing seat
None of these - Show me all
Show results!

What carriers are right for my family?

What type of carriers are you interested in? (Select as many as you like)

Soft Structured
Mei Tei

How would you like to carry your baby? (Select as many as you like)

In front with baby facing inward
In front with baby facing outward
Hip Carry
Back Carry
Does not matter

Will you be using the carrier for a new baby under 3 months old?


Are you ok with carriers that require a separate insert for newborns?


Please enter the age and/or weight of the child you would like to carry (optional)


Do you need a carrier that can be used into toddlerhood?

Yes, up to 36 months or more
Yes, up to 24 months or more
No, show me all

Do you have a specific budget in mind?

Under $25
Under $50
Under $100
No, Show me all
Show results!

Compare Strollers

Please enter a valid zip code
Please enter a valid zip code
Please enter a valid email